Black Men and Broken Homes: Accountability Without Pandering
- Jun 18, 2025
- 3 min read
Accountability isn’t hate—it’s healing. Black men and women both play a role in breaking or building the home.
Let’s get something straight up front: I’m not pandering to men. I don’t date them. I don’t deal with them romantically, and this isn’t about being seen as agreeable. This is about truth. And from where I sit, the truth is that yes—many Black men do play a role in the cycle of broken homes in our community.
That doesn’t mean all Black men are the problem. Some of the best, most responsible people I know are Black men—men who are attentive, nurturing, financially stable, and committed to their children. Any woman would be lucky to build with them. But let’s not pretend they’re the majority when it comes to fatherhood outcomes in our community.
K. Michelle said it directly to Cam Newton on his Funky Friday podcast: Black men need to take accountability for the state of Black families. And she’s absolutely right. Here’s what’s painful: over 64% of Black children are raised in single-parent homes, and most of those parents are women. That means many Black men were raised by single mothers. That alone should be enough reason for them to respect women more—not less.
But instead of learning from the hardship their mothers endured, many repeat the cycle. They create children with no plan to be consistent fathers or reliable partners, then move on to the next situation like it’s nothing. For example; Duke Dennis, the steamer (but that’s a topic for another day).
That’s one side of the coin.
The other side? Women who keep choosing men that are clearly unfit to father children. Men who already have three, four, five kids by different women, with messy drama and no structure. You’re not the exception. You’re the pattern continuing. And at a certain point, it says more about you than it does about him.
This isn’t judgment—it’s observation. I truly don’t understand how some women see these red flags and still say, “I want to be next.” It’s one thing to be lied to. It’s another to willingly become the sixth baby mama of a man who’s never shown fatherly qualities.
And when women try to speak up—when we try to say, “Sis, you deserve better”—we get labeled as men-haters / bashers by these ‘pick me’ women. Let’s clear something up right now:
A ‘pick me’ is not a woman who holds other women accountable.
A pick me is a woman who will always choose a man over her kids, her friends, her own well-being, and even reality. She’ll bash other women to stay in a man’s good graces, even if that man is actively horrible to her. That is the definition of a pick me. And unfortunately, many rational women get cut off for calling that behavior what it is.
Meanwhile, these same women will turn around and post “Black men ain’t sh*t” like they weren’t active participants in every single toxic decision that led them there. That’s not universal truth—that’s personal taste.
You picked struggle love. Over and over again.
Good Black men do exist. But they don’t get praised. They don’t get chosen. Because they don’t bring chaos, emotional highs, or reckless energy. They bring peace—and a lot of people still confuse peace with boredom.
Black men need to do better. Black women need to choose better. No one’s off the hook.
We have to stop romanticizing dysfunction. Stop glamorizing trauma bonding. And stop building homes we know are going to fall apart. Broken homes aren’t accidents—they’re built by poor choices, unresolved wounds, and ego.
It’s time to break that cycle. Not just talk about it. Do something different.
Continue following the Apples to Oranges Newsletter for future updates.
Comments